No comment on Orijen because my doggies had a particularly bad experience on it and therefore, I'm completely biased. On the surface, it seemed like an awesome food, but it just went horribly wrong with my doggies...
Taste of the wild has ocean fish (mystery fish that can vary, which isn't good for sensitive doggies, imo), and way too many potatoes in it- potatoes, sweet potatoes, potato fiber... It's not bad, but for the amount you'll pay...
I'm always a fan of the Evo. Jemma's on the Evo large bites now (chicken) after Nature's Variety Instinct stocks dried up around here. Her coat is looking awesome and shiny and her stools are smaller (they were huge on the instinct, HUGE!).
Go Natural, the grain free chicken, duck, turkey seems ok, but I don't know why they put yeast in there when so many dogs have yeast problems. And lipase? What's that about? I don't think I'd want my doggies to have any lipase. I mean, in theory, it probably is supposed to help them digest the fat, but in reality, I can't imagine it doesn't also break down surrounding cell membranes, no? Lipase is scary stuff...
And even though we bugged petcurean to no end about the vitamin K (they say it's not menadione), they still haven't changed it three years later to make it clearer... Hmm.
Oh, but if you do try the evo, after a while, if he's like Boo & gets constipated, you might have to add a bit of food that's more cerealy to it. I add Merrick Wilderness Blend to Boo's evo RM, but I think that's got lamb. It's more red meat based.. I think.
Anyway, just a heads up about that.. um.. issue. :D
Lucy and Riley both do awesome on the Orijen as does my mom's choc lab and my uncle's senior lab. I couldn't get my guys to handle the evo at all, finally gave up. My mom has also tried the Go Natural Salmon and Oatmeal and has had great results with that as well. I've been looking at Taste of the Wild as it has a better price point but is made by Diamond Foods and not sure how I feel about that. Good luck!
5 comments:
No comment on Orijen because my doggies had a particularly bad experience on it and therefore, I'm completely biased. On the surface, it seemed like an awesome food, but it just went horribly wrong with my doggies...
Taste of the wild has ocean fish (mystery fish that can vary, which isn't good for sensitive doggies, imo), and way too many potatoes in it- potatoes, sweet potatoes, potato fiber... It's not bad, but for the amount you'll pay...
I'm always a fan of the Evo. Jemma's on the Evo large bites now (chicken) after Nature's Variety Instinct stocks dried up around here. Her coat is looking awesome and shiny and her stools are smaller (they were huge on the instinct, HUGE!).
Go Natural, the grain free chicken, duck, turkey seems ok, but I don't know why they put yeast in there when so many dogs have yeast problems. And lipase? What's that about? I don't think I'd want my doggies to have any lipase. I mean, in theory, it probably is supposed to help them digest the fat, but in reality, I can't imagine it doesn't also break down surrounding cell membranes, no? Lipase is scary stuff...
And even though we bugged petcurean to no end about the vitamin K (they say it's not menadione), they still haven't changed it three years later to make it clearer... Hmm.
Yeah, not a fan.
Oh, but if you do try the evo, after a while, if he's like Boo & gets constipated, you might have to add a bit of food that's more cerealy to it. I add Merrick Wilderness Blend to Boo's evo RM, but I think that's got lamb. It's more red meat based.. I think.
Anyway, just a heads up about that.. um.. issue. :D
Orijen: gave my kids dull coats and lots of stinkies.
Evo: awesome for dakotah, got maika constipated like cement.
Go Natural: only tried the grain formula from a while back, don't remember much about it.
Luckily Prin's got a much better summary than I do, LOL!
Lucy and Riley both do awesome on the Orijen as does my mom's choc lab and my uncle's senior lab. I couldn't get my guys to handle the evo at all, finally gave up. My mom has also tried the Go Natural Salmon and Oatmeal and has had great results with that as well. I've been looking at Taste of the Wild as it has a better price point but is made by Diamond Foods and not sure how I feel about that.
Good luck!
Thanks everyone. I have decided to go with Evo large bites. Lets see how that goes...
Post a Comment